Companies are shown in order of their real customer rating, sourced from Google, BBB, and other public review platforms. See our full company research for sources and dates.
Best Choice Roofing specializes in roofing only, with real strength in insurance-claim navigation and Owens Corning Platinum Preferred certification. Customer experiences run the gamut from smooth, same-day insurance-assisted replacements to detailed complaints about post-install leaks and slow callbacks, so get any leak/warranty response-time commitment in writing at signing. Because they're roofing-only, homeowners bundling multiple exterior projects will need a separate contractor for the rest.
Long Home Products has served the East Coast for 65+ years across bath, roofing, and windows, and reviews are strongest on crew professionalism and cleanup once a job is underway. Their marketing outreach is active — if you're not currently in the market, let them know directly and ask to be removed from their contact list.
Home Genius Exteriors holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status (top 1% of contractors) plus James Hardie Elite and CertainTeed 5-Star certifications, and reviews back up the credentials — homeowners repeatedly single out their dedicated project managers for staying in touch throughout the job. Crews are described as fast and considerate of property across windows, roofing, siding, and gutters, not just one specialty. Their promotional "50% off materials" offer explicitly excludes windows and doors — confirm what's actually included before you count on it.
Power Home Remodeling is one of the largest multi-trade exterior remodelers in the country (windows, roofing, siding, doors, gutters), using a "blind pricing" model and their own Project Pulse app to track your job. Reviews consistently praise crew professionalism and finished quality; the most common real feedback is about the door-to-door sales approach itself, which is simply how they generate most leads — you're free to schedule a consultation on your own timeline instead.
Victory Home Remodeling is both the manufacturer and installer for its roofing and siding products in the NJ/NY/PA/DE/MD corridor, which real customers cite as a reason for trusting the finished result — one company accountable start to finish rather than a sales layer over a third-party installer. Reviews consistently describe crews as professional and respectful of property, and the GAF Master Elite designation (top 2% of GAF-certified contractors) backs their roofing warranty.
Pinnacle Home Improvement is a Southeast roofing and windows specialist (GA/TN/NC/AL/FL) with reviews praising fast, clean, professional installer crews and hands-on help navigating storm insurance claims. As with Long Home, if you've already decided against a purchase, ask directly to be taken off their follow-up call list.
Erie Home specializes in stone-coated steel roofing — a heavier-duty alternative to asphalt shingles with a 50-year transferable warranty — and reviews back up their one-day installation claim even on large roofs, with repeated praise for thorough cleanup. Metal roofing costs more upfront than asphalt shingles; the tradeoff is longevity and storm resistance, which matters most in hail- or wind-prone regions.
FHIA Remodeling has been a Florida-focused remodeler for 50+ years and recently became part of the Renuity national platform (some listings now show as "Renuity of South Florida") — a regional brand within a national platform, similar to Mad City in the Midwest. Reviews are strongest on their impact-window and roofing installation quality; as with any brand transitioning into a larger platform, get warranty terms confirmed in writing since contract language can shift during a rebrand.
Hansons is a Great Lakes multi-trade specialist running its own in-house crews across windows, roofing, and siding, backed by a four-tier Smart Choice warranty system (only the top Smart Choice tier carries the full Lifetime Guarantee — ask which tier your quote includes). Customer reviews consistently describe the sales process as informative rather than pushy, and installation crews are frequently praised for speed on same-day multi-window jobs. Hansons is also an exclusive ProVia siding dealer in its markets, which is worth asking about if you're bundling projects.
Clear Choice markets itself across New England and Pennsylvania, but our own lead-routing data shows their most consistently active market concentrated around Harrisburg, PA — a regional specialist, not a national company. Reviews reflect a company accountable for a tight footprint: crews are praised for communication and clean installs on siding, gutter, and roofing work. Their fiber cement expertise includes James Hardie certification, and they offer detailed written estimates with itemized material and labor breakdowns. Confirm your specific ZIP is in their active service area before requesting a quote.
DaBella is a GAF Master Elite and James Hardie Elite Preferred contractor offering roofing, siding, and windows with financing connected through unaffiliated third-party lenders (DaBella itself doesn't originate the loan). Independent review platforms show a wide range depending on where in the customer journey the review was left — ratings skew highest at the initial in-home consultation stage and are more mixed once you look past that first impression, which is worth knowing going in. Get the full warranty terms and financing APR in writing before signing, and don't feel pressured to decide in a single visit.
Homefix Custom Remodeling is a GAF Master Elite contractor (100% Lifetime Guarantee eligible) focused on the Mid-Atlantic, and long-tenured customers — some 10–20 years in — specifically cite durability holding up over time. As with several door-to-door-marketed regional contractors, be direct about your preferred contact method during the initial outreach if you'd rather schedule by phone or online.
Lednor Home Solutions is the regional Gutter Helmet dealer for Maryland, DC, and Virginia, and reviews consistently praise punctual, clean installation crews. A recurring, fair theme in reviews is scheduling speed for repair/warranty service calls — ask about typical response time for service requests before you sign.
| Company | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Best Choice Roofing | ⭐ 5.0 | 61 |
| Long Home Products | ⭐ 4.9 | 6,000+ |
| Home Genius Exteriors | ⭐ 4.8 | 2,377 |
| Power Home Remodeling | ⭐ 4.6 | 4,852 |
| Victory Home Remodeling | ⭐ 4.6 | 2,518 |
| Pinnacle Home Improvement | ⭐ 4.6 | 1,093 |
| Erie Home | ⭐ 4.5 | 1,400+ |
| FHIA Remodeling | ⭐ 4.5 | 3,923 |
| Hansons | ⭐ 4.4 | 4,230 |
| Clear Choice Home Improvement | ⭐ 4.4 | 857 |
| DaBella | ⭐ 4.4 | 3,000+ |
| Homefix Custom Remodeling | ⭐ 4.3 | 671 |
| Lednor Home Solutions | ⭐ 4.2 | 344 |
The right roof replacement company depends on your budget, project scope, and location. Here's what to look for:
These are the questions homeowners ask most often before starting this project - what it costs, how long it takes, what a fair quote looks like and which details change the price. Each answer below is written to stand on its own, so you can read just the one you need.
